Capitalist investors from developed countries who decry government regulators maintain an unshaken and devout faith in the power of Chinese state intervention to stimulate growth. I believe they would have more luck at the gaming tables in Macau
I gave one of my best pieces of investment advice over five years ago. In a letter to the Financial Times published on 6 October 2006, I wrote “the best investment in China will be the casinos of Macau, not state-owned banks.” The letter was certainly prescient. Revenue from Macau casinos has risen 700% since then. Shares in the largest state-owned bank, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China have risen only 30%. Sadly the best way for investors to profit from those casinos came in the fall of 2009 after the IPOs of Wynn Macau and Sands China.
These stocks came out at a fortuitous time. China was beginning a massive stimulus package. With such a flash flood of money, it was no surprise that a lot of it leaked out on to the gambling tables of Macau. These leaks were reflected in the casinos’ profits and share prices. Wynn rose 170% by 2011. The Sands did even better. Its shares increased 200% by May of 2012.
As I pointed out in my piece published last January, much of this money was flight capital. During the stimulus induced boom years from 2009 to the beginning of this year many wealthy Chinese used Macau to move their profits out of the country. In 2011 mainlanders set a new record for visits to Macau. The total number of Chinese visitors rose 22% to 16.1 million making up almost 60% of visitors. Once in Macau there are many different ways to launder money, according to one local professor, “more than we can think of”. But things are changing.
There are many indicators used for the Chinese economy. The problem is that the official numbers can be a bit dodgy. Even the heir apparent to become the next premier of China, Li Keqiang, has stated that China’s broad measures of economic growth are “ ‘man-made’ and therefore unreliable.” Li and many other economists like to rely on other indicators like electricity consumption, volume of rail cargo and the disbursement of bank loans.
The problem with these indicators in an economy that is heavily controlled by the state is that they can be manipulated. The numbers are created by state-controlled institutions. In a country where information is tightly controlled, the published numbers can be easily changed to suit appearances.
Macau is different. The revenue numbers are available from publically listed companies often controlled by American firms. They are all but beyond the reach of the Chinese authorities and they show something very interesting. Basically gaming revenue growth has been declining for the past two years. Revenue growth hit a high of over 80% in early 2010. Since then it has been falling. In July, 2012 it rose only 1.7% down from 7% as recently as May. Visitor growth has also been declining and this year it actually started falling. The casinos share prices have been falling as well. Sands China is down 30% since April. MGM is down 20% since May.
Most economists and analysts are not worried about this dramatic slowdown. In a world hooked on government stimulus, they believe this is good news, because it will lead to government action. The irony is that the government has been acting. The central bank lowered interest rates and made the third reserve cut in six months. The Chinese government’s lending goal of 8 to 8.5 trillion yuan for 2012 is about the same as the amount of new loans in 2010 and 2011, but the banks are missing their targets because of weak demand.
Although the economy of China and Macau are declining, there is still a boom in wealthy Chinese leaving the country along with large amounts of their money. China has over one million citizens with assets over 10 million yuan ($1.6 million). Like Brazil, Venezuela, Argentina, Russia, Spain and Greece, they are exporting themselves and their money. Over 16% have immigrated, 44% plan to do so and 85% have sent their children abroad for education. Unlike many western commentators, they are very gloomy on China’s prospect. Only 28% believe in China’s prospects over the next two years half the number of last year.
In fact so much money is now leaving China that the country reported a deficit in its balance of payments in the second quarter for the first time in 14 years. This occurred despite the fact that the current account is still in surplus, because China’s exports exceed its imports. Foreign direct investment (FDI) also remained strong, but not strong enough to balance the $110 billion that left.
There is a certain irony here. The capitalist investors from developed countries, who decry government regulators, maintain an unshaken and devout faith in the power of state intervention to stimulate growth. Personally I believe they would have more luck at the gaming tables in Macau.
(William Gamble is president of Emerging Market Strategies. An international lawyer and economist, he developed his theories beginning with his first hand experience and business dealings in the Russia starting in 1993. Mr Gamble holds two graduate law degrees. He was educated at Institute D'Etudes Politique, Trinity College, University of Miami School of Law, and University of Virginia Darden Graduate School of Business Administration. He was a member of the bar in three states, over four different federal courts and has spoken four languages. Mr Gamble can be contacted at [email protected] or [email protected].)
Some Kingfisher flights from Mumbai have already been cancelled due to the pilots strike and many more cancellations are to follow
A close below 5,342 may see the Nifty slip to the level of 5,250
The market saw its third weekly close in the positive mainly on hopes that central banks across the world will step in with fresh initiative to spur growth in the light of dismal economic indicators. A fall in India’s headline inflation for July also supported the gains in the holiday-shortened week. Among economic events, July consumer price index (CPI) based inflation, to be announced on Tuesday, will be keenly watched.
The Sensex closed the week 133 points (0.76%) higher at 17,691 and the Nifty added 46 points (0.86%) to settle at 5,366. Going ahead, the market is likely to move sideways. However, if Friday’s low of 5,342 is broken and the Nifty settles below that level, we may see the index slipping to the level of 5,250.
The market closed in the green on Monday on a smart recovery in late trade. A fall in headline inflation for July and supportive global cues ensured a positive close for the second day. All markets in India were closed on Wednesday on account of the Independence Day holiday.
The benchmarks settled lower on Thursday on selling pressure in FMCG, metals and consumer durables sectors. Despite falling to the day’s low following the CAG report, select buying ensured a green close on Friday.
In the sectoral space, BSE Oil & Gas and BSE Auto gained 2% each while BSE Metal (down 2%) and BSE Power (down 1%) were the losers.
The top Sensex gainers in the week were Reliance Industries, Mahindra & Mahindra, Tata Motors (up 4% each), HDFC (up 3%) and Bharti Airtel (up 2%). Hindalco Industries (down 7%), Tata Power (down 3%), Sun Pharma, ITC and NTPC (down 2% each) settled at the bottom of the index.
The Nifty was led by Ranbaxy Laboratories, IDFC (up 7% each), RIL, M&M and HCL Technologies (up 4% each). The top losers were Hindalco Ind (down 8%), BPCL, Tata Power, Ambuja Cements (down 3% each) and NTPC (down 2%).
Hit hard by slowing overseas demand, India's exports in July contracted 14.8% to $22.4 billion in July. Imports too declined by 7.6% to $37.9 billion, leaving a trade deficit of $15.5 billion for the month.
Headline Inflation declined to 6.87% in July as the rate of price rise of the food articles category eased a little. Inflation, as measured by the Wholesale Price Index (WPI), was 7.25% in June and stood at 9.36% in July last year. Meanwhile, food inflation declined to 10.06% in July, from 10.81% in June.
The CAG on Friday charged the government of allocating coal blocks, power projects and land for the Delhi's airport at a pittance, costing the exchequer crores of rupees in lost revenues. Meanwhile, The government rubbished the CAG’s findings that private firms had got “undue benefits” to the tune of Rs3.06 lakh crore in coal, aviation and power sectors, arguing that the calculations were ‘misleading’ and faulty and accused the auditor of not following its mandate.
The BJP has demanded the resignation of prime minister Manmohan Singh taking “moral, political and personal” responsibility for the wrongful loss due to coal block allocations.
On the global front, US stocks settled higher for the sixth week on better-than-expected economic indicators. Analysts opine that the market is likely to face a challenge as September is seen as a month of heightened trading activity coupled with an increase in volatility.
European markets also settled higher as policymakers were making concerted efforts to find solutions to the continent’s debt crisis.