Best Fund Houses

Last year, when we analysed the best fund houses, there were 29 of them operating in India; many more were awaiting SEBI’s nod to enter the Indian market. That number has now gone up to 33 with 284 equity growth schemes on offer to investors. We bring you a rating of all the fund houses. We have used the same methodology that we had evolved last year to help select the best ones based on a complex and unique combination of data for the past three years.

As you are aware, the commonest approach to rank funds is to choose from the recent top performers but, as we have shown several times, many funds do well for a brief period (called winning streaks) and then start slipping. You can tweak this method in a variety of ways but any selection based on the results of recent performance is bound to be fundamentally flawed.

Another approach is to find out how good a fund family is. Are there patterns in their performance? Do well-performing fund houses maintain their high batting averages over a period? The most obvious way to find that out is to aggregate the returns of all schemes of the fund house in a certain category over a period and rank them. This gives us the benefit of identifying consistently good performers across different styles and focus. One particular scheme may have been lucky to be on a winning streak, but it is doubtful if a fund house, as a whole, will be lucky when its performance is measured across all schemes.

So, when the next new scheme of a top-performing fund house comes along, you know that it has better pedigree. But considering performance in isolation is not enough. We have demonstrated this through many separate analyses. The past cannot be easily and simply extrapolated into the future. To make our findings more authentic, we added other parameters that are uniquely relevant in the Indian context. These make our ranking of the top fund houses completely different from the general approach adopted by others.   

The Top Honours

We have always maintained that being on top is one thing; remaining there is another. A fund house which is among the top performers at one time may not necessarily repeat its performance the second time. Consistency in remaining at the top is what actually counts. Look at the top performers of our list this time and it would be clear what we mean by consistency. Deutsche Mutual, which was languishing in the middle order last year, has jumped to the top position this year with a composite score of 85. This is primarily due to a robust performance of its schemes - it gave an annualised return of 51% over the past three years. Though the fund house still lags behind other major fund houses in terms of size, it hasn’t launched any scheme in rising market cycles. We value that approach. Its riskiness is also low which has pushed it up the order. Among others that managed a high rank were Morgan Stanley, HDFC Mutual, Tata Mutual and Franklin Templeton. What has given them a place among the top five performers? It is a combination of four factors, which includes higher returns, a lower downside risk, minimum number of launches in rising market cycles, and a reasonable size.

What happened to the toppers of last year? DSP Merrill Lynch scored a composite score of 51 this year and was at the 11th position. What has pushed it down the ladder is the higher number of funds launched in rising market cycles. Fund managers at Sundaram Mutual have been taking greater risk than others; that has pushed the fund house lower down the ladder. Also, coinciding with rising market cycles, it has launched a total of five new schemes, three of which were launched in 2007. Look at Reliance Mutual as well. This fund house too has slipped because of the higher number of new schemes it launched in rising market cycles and the higher risk taken by its fund managers.

The Laggards


Among fund houses that have lagged are: JM Financial, DBS Chola, LIC Mutual and Fidelity. JM Mutual failed on all the parameters. It launched seven new funds in the past three years; in terms of returns too it was way below the others on a three-year basis. DBS Chola too scored low because of the riskiness of its portfolio and has launched four new funds in a rising market cycle. LIC was among the losers last year; it has done equally badly this year with a composite score of 25, thanks to its poor performance. Fidelity scored low on all four parameters and ended with a composite score of 27.

The older, bank-sponsored mutual funds in their new avatars have done comparatively better this time. Look at Canbank (now Canara Robeco). It emerged quite high with a composite score of 56. It has maintained a fairly reasonable risk profile and has launched just two new funds in rising market cycles during the past three years. On the returns front too, it hasn’t done very badly but the only parameter which pulls it down is its size. Here are some more observations from our study.

Winners & Losers: It is worthwhile reiterating what we said last time. To start with, avoid fund families that are consistently poor performers and yet greedily launch new funds. This is a deadly combination. Which are the ones that qualify to be in this list? JM Financial, UTI and LIC. The best fund families usually have top-quality fund managers. Good fund managers are characterised by their depth of experience and have a cerebral approach. S Naganath of DSP Merrill Lynch, Prashant Jain of HDFC and Sanjay Sinha of SBI belong to this category. If these fund managers quit, take a hard look at the new manager. If you are not a risk-averse investor, take a look at Reliance. Its fund managers have a more trading-oriented style but deliver a good performance.

Mix and Match: Mutual funds are the biggest proponents of the theory of diversification. We suggest you diversify your portfolio over various fund houses and not just various schemes and themes. For instance, SBI launched a comparatively larger number of new funds in rising market cycles over the past three years, yet it has been able to deliver good returns. It was among the top five fund houses when it came to returns. On the other hand, Sahara may have a very good risk profile but it fails when it comes to delivering returns and is also among the smallest in terms of size.

Size Does Matter: Large- and mega-cap stocks are good bets to avoid irrational market mood swings. By the same logic, fund houses with larger assets under management (AUMs) seem to be doing well and have a balanced overall performance. Look at Reliance. It manages Rs58,000 crore in assets and has managed to return an annualised 24% over the past three years. The same stands true of ICICI Prudential. It has an asset size of Rs51,000 crore and has returned an annualised 29%.

It is not that the bigger the fund house, the better the performance. Reliance with the largest AUMs has given a reasonable return over the past three years while ICICI Prudential was also among the toppers in providing returns, despite its large AUMs. UTI stands out as an exception. It has a large size but is way below other fund houses in terms of returns. Kotak Mutual, with a much smaller size, is much better when it comes to providing returns. 

Timing The Market

Fund management is a business and fund companies make money on the money they are able to collect from the public through existing as well as new schemes that they launch. Investor ignorance and lack of adequate regulatory oversight are two principal reasons why fund houses prefer to launch new schemes in different flavours irrespective of investor needs. One of the four parameters of ranking fund houses is their greed for raising fresh money from the public as reflected in their hurry to launch NFOs, especially during rising market cycles. To get the public’s attention and interest, fund houses launch NFOs with funny ideas sold with marketing gimmicks and lavish incentives for distributors. Many of these ideas are untested and unproven. This is a peculiar Indian trend, to segregate which we have aggregated NFOs launched by fund houses timed with a strong market uptrend.

We have identified four major periods of uptrend in the past three years which have encouraged fund houses to launch new schemes. Among the 28 fund houses, only three went without launching any schemes in rising market cycles. Benchmark, BOB and Escorts were the only ones to have launched the least number of schemes during these periods. Funds that have been slow to raise money during rising market cycles were: Canara Robeco, Fidelity, Franklin Templeton, HDFC Mutual and LIC; they launched two schemes each. ABN AMRO, HSBC, Kotak and Tata Mutual launched three schemes each while DBS Chola, Standard Chartered, PRINCIPAL, Sahara, SBI and Sundaram were more aggressive in launching schemes during bull periods. Those that have raised large sums through new fund offerings were: ING (six), Reliance Mutual (six), Birla (seven), JM Financial (seven), UTI (seven), DSP Merrill Lynch (eight) and ICICI Prudential (nine). 

Our study covers a period of three years, which have been great for Indian investors, more particularly the fund industry which has reached a critical mass during this period. From 29, the number of fund houses operating in India has gone up to 33. However, we have considered only 28, which have been operational in the Indian market for more than three years, and left the five new entrants out of the scope of our study. We ranked the performance of these 28 funds over the past three years by four factors. First, the average performance of their equity growth funds (these include diversified, sector and index funds) over the past three years.

How did we do this? We considered all the 284 growth schemes in those three categories presently on offer by various fund houses to calculate the average returns provided by them during the past three years. For all those schemes which have been in existence for more than three years, we have considered their returns over the past three years and annualised them. For schemes which have been in existence for less than three years but more than one year, we have considered annualised returns since inception; for those which have been in existence for less than a year, we have considered their absolute returns since inception. We then took an average of returns provided by various schemes of each fund house to arrive at an aggregate average return for each.

Second, since we believe that returns are just one part of the story, we considered the downside risk associated with each of the schemes by calculating the Sortino ratio. An average of the Sortino for schemes offered by each fund house gave us the measure of the downside risk associated with each of the fund house. Third, one unique criterion that we had introduced last year was the number of new funds offered by fund houses when the going is good (periods of rising markets). We provide negative weightage - the more the NFOs, the lower is the rank. The fourth factor that we considered was the size of assets managed. The larger the size, the better it is. A composite ranking based on all these four factors gave us our final list of the best fund houses.

User

5 Hottest Growth Sectors

These are the five best of the 51 sectors we track. Two of them will remain hot in 2006,...

Premium Content
Monthly Digital Access

Subscribe

Already A Subscriber?
Login
Yearly Digital+Print Access

Subscribe

Moneylife Magazine Subscriber or MSSN member?
Login

Yearly Subscriber Login

Enter the mail id that you want to use & click on Go. We will send you a link to your email for verficiation
Personal finance Monday

ICICI Prudential MF unveils ICICI Prudential Fixed Maturity Plan-Series 54-18 Months Plan A; IDFC Mutual Fund floats IDFC Fixed Maturity Plan Bi-Monthly Series-1; SBI Mutual Fund launches SBI Debt Fund Series-180 Days 12; Morgan Stanley MF announces dividend for two funds; BSNL introduces STV-175 in Himachal Pradesh; Idea Cellular launches Diwali offer in Gujarat

ICICI Prudential MF unveils ICICI Prudential Fixed Maturity Plan-Series 54-18 Months Plan A

ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund has launched ICICI Prudential Fixed Maturity Plan-Series 54-18 Months Plan A, a close-ended income scheme.
The investment objective of the plan is to generate regular returns by investing in fixed income securities/debt instruments which mature on or before the date of maturity of the plan/scheme.
The tenor of the plan is 550 days. The plan will invest 100% amount in government securities and money-market instruments having low to medium profile. During the new fund offer (NFO), the units will be offered at face value of Rs10 per unit. The NFO opens on 1st November and closes on 15th November. The minimum investment amount is Rs5,000. Since the plan will be listed on the stock exchange, load will not be applicable. Brokerage on sales of the units of the scheme on the stock exchanges shall be borne by the investors.
CRISIL Composite Bond Fund Index is the benchmark index. Chaitanya Pande is the fund manager.

IDFC Mutual Fund floats IDFC Fixed Maturity Plan Bi-Monthly Series-1

IDFC Mutual Fund has launched IDFC Fixed Maturity Plan Bi-Monthly Series-1, a close-ended income scheme.
The investment objective is to generate income by investing in debt and money-market instruments maturing on or before the maturity of the scheme. The scheme will invest 100% of the amount in debt and money-market instruments having low to medium risk.
The duration of the scheme is two months. The scheme offers growth and dividend option. During the new fund offer (NFO), the units will be offered at face value of Rs10 per unit. The NFO opens on 1st November and closes on 2nd November. The minimum investment amount is Rs10,000. The minimum target amount is Rs1 crore. The exit load for the scheme is nil.
CRISIL Composite Bond Fund Index is the benchmark index. The scheme will be managed by Anupam Joshi.

SBI Mutual Fund launches SBI Debt Fund Series-180 Days 12

SBI Mutual Fund has launched SBI Debt Fund Series-180 Days 12, a close-ended income scheme.
The investment objective is to provide regular income, liquidity and returns to the investors through investments in debt instruments such as government securities, PSU and corporate bonds and money-market instruments maturing on or before the maturity of the scheme.
The scheme will invest 100% of the amount in government securities and money-market instruments having low to medium risk. The scheme offers growth and dividend (payout) option. Since the scheme will be listed on stock exchange, there will not be any exit load.
During the new fund offer (NFO), the units will be offered at face value of Rs10 per unit. The NFO opens on 1st November and closes on 2nd November. The minimum investment amount is Rs5,000. The minimum target amount is Rs1 crore. CRISIL Liquid Fund Index is the benchmark index. The scheme will be managed by Rajeev Radhakrishnan.

Morgan Stanley MF announces dividend for two funds

Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund (MSMF) today announced a maiden dividend of Re1 per unit on the face value of Rs10 in Morgan Stanley A.C.E. (Across Capitalisations Equity) Fund. MSMF also announced a dividend of Rs1.50 per unit on the face value of Rs10 in Morgan Stanley Growth Fund (MSGF). The record date for both funds is 4 November 2010.
Morgan Stanley A.C.E. Fund was launched in April 2008. Morgan Stanley A.C.E. Fund is a multi-cap fund that invests across market caps. Morgan Stanley Growth Fund was launched in 1994 as a close-ended fund.

BSNL introduces STV-175 in Himachal Pradesh

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd (BSNL) has introduced a special tariff voucher (STV) 175 with unlimited free local calling facility in Himachal Pradesh.
The new STV-175 comes at Rs175 with the talk time of Rs100 and validity of 30 days. With this pack, all local calls to BSNL network (mobile/landline) in Himachal Pradesh will be free. While other network local and STD calls will be charged at 1.2paisa/second. The subscriber also gets free 50 local and 50 national SMS valid for 30 days.

Idea Cellular launches Diwali offer in Gujarat

Mobile operator Idea Cellular has launched festival benefits pack for new customers offering special tariff and additional benefits of SMS and GPRS usage in Gujarat.
The Idea subscribers can enjoy the festival benefits pack which has in-built tariff advantage of all local Idea to Idea calls at 1 paisa per two seconds. The pack also offers 73,000 free SMS for a year and 200 MB of GPRS usage absolutely free for seven days.
Additionally, Idea subscribers can also opt for a wide range of special recharges such as discounted night calling free for a year; 12,900 free SMS; 1,290 MB of free data usage; and STD calls for Re1 per three minutes during the festive season.

User

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
  Loading...
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email

BUY NOW

The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)