AgustaWestland had kept Rs217 crore for bribe, says a report

According to the report filed by Italian investigators in an Italian court, the middlemen had agreed for a 7.5% commission in the Rs3,600 crore for 12 VVIP helicopters. Finally, the kickbacks were around Rs362 crore

The Italy government-owned AgustaWestland had allegedly kept aside Rs217 crore as part of ‘corrupt activity’ to bag India’s Rs3,600 crore deal and its choppers became eligible only after certain required parameters were altered in the tender document.


According to the report filed by Italian investigators in an Italian court, the middlemen had agreed for a 7.5% commission in the Rs3,600 crore for 12 VVIP helicopters. Finally, the kickbacks were around Rs362 crore.


The payment of bribes through contracts between firms registered in Tunisia and India, was “still underway” when the scam was unearthed.


The report said CEO of Finmeccanica Giuseppe Orsi and AgustaWestland CEO Bruno Spagnolini had paid 30 million euros (Rs217 crore) to one of the main middlemen Christian Michel.


The arrested CEOs of the two companies had also “paid Guido Ralph Hashcke and Carlo Gerosa (two other alleged middlemen), through a consultancy contract between AW Spa and Gordian Services Sarl an amount of 400,000 euros (about Rs2.8 crore), of which 100,000 euros (Rs72 lakh) were paid cash to the Tyagi brothers (Julie, Docsa and Sandeep).”


The report suggests that the middlemen had close contacts with the family of former IAF Chief Air Chief marshal SP Tyagi, particularly his three cousins.


One middlemen named ‘ADR’ has claimed in his interrogation that the first meeting of one of the middlemen Zappa with Tyagi happened at the time when the tender was in the Request for Information (RFI) phase.


The middleman reportedly claimed he had paid around Rs72 lakh to the three cousins of ACM Tyagi. They alleged that Tyagi used to brief them about the developments in the tender during their meetings, according to the report of the Italian investigators.


The report said “Haschke and Gerosa, through the Tyagi brothers, in turn through their cousin ACM SP Tyagi, managed first to change the tender details, in a way to favour, modifying the 'operational ceiling' from 18,000 to 15,000 feet of altitude, thus allowing AgustaWestland Spa (which otherwise could not have even submitted an offer) to take part in the tender.”


After the arrest of Orsi and Spagnolini in Italy, India has put on hold the delivery of three AW-101 choppers to be delivered in March along with the remaining six.


The payment for the choppers has also been stopped and defence ministry has stated that because of the integrity pact, it can get back all the money paid by it for the deal.




4 years ago

In India,Every Accused simply Denies the Charges / Allegations against him Bluntly and Our Courts say it is for Posecutors to Prove the Allegations Beyond any Doubt.CBI can Investigate only if Govt.Orders so.These Bribery Allegations are Exposed since One Year by Media ,but Govt.Intellengensies do not look at them.Some more Damages are Happened within this Year, which might have been avoided if Govt. has any system for Intelligence wings to examine Media Allegations and submit PrimaFacie Examining reports to Govt.,so that Corrective Action taken in time.They should have checked Thyagi's Cousins Bank Accouns and Phones Tapped,so that Proof exists if Allegations Prove Correct.
( 2 ) Abroad ,accused accepts their mistakes Quickly but here Accused Denies till Judge Prounces Judgement after cases are filed.

AMC NoAH: Bringing transparency through self-regulation

A new sub-group carved out within Association of Medical Consultants hopes to achieve uniformity in the common operating practices as well as bring more nursing homes in the cashless network

The Association of Medical Consultants (AMC) aims to address the needs of the insurance sector and nursing homes by creating a group called Network of AMC Hospitals (NoAH). Out of the 1,500 nursing homes within the AMC fold, 217 have agreed to be part of AMC NoAH. This number is expected to grow to 300 by March 2013. These nursing homes will offer common billing format, common cashless authorisation format and display of key hospital tariffs.

One of the major issues for customers of medical services is the lack of transparency in the charges by nursing homes and hospitals as well as possible differential pricing if the customer is insured. AMC NoAH nursing homes will display the key tariff charges at the reception of the hospital for information of the patients. These charges would be levied across the board and shall not vary for insurance or non-insurance patients.

At the Bombay High Court hearing (12 February 2013) of the public interest litigation filed by social activist Gaurang Damani, the AMC was able to come up with indicative rates for 42 standard ailments with disclaimers about the rates excluding professional fees and surgeon fees, which may vary. The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority’s (IRDA) legal representative agreed to review the documentation of rates prepared by the AMC.

AMC NoAH has tied up with Bajaj Allianz to offer its policyholders cashless facility in all member nursing homes. It will also offer 7.5% discount on the bill to the insured. Star Health and other insurance companies may tie-up with AMC NoAH. The progress to bring more nursing homes to be part of government insurance companies’ preferred provider network (PPN) has been at a snail’s pace. Even New India Assurance’s general manager who attended Moneylife Foundation’s recent mediclaim seminar agreed that progress is slow in Mumbai and Bangalore. Whether AMC NoAH can resolve the standoff between government insurers/TPAs (third party administrators) and nursing homes can only be known in future.

Another benefit for consumers will be that the AMC NoAH nursing homes will need compulsory accreditation from the group and hence standards will improve. The levels will be minimum, optimum and excellent. Currently, the accreditation is optional for AMC members. It is obvious that some AMC member nursing homes may not want to be part of self regulated group (AMC NoAH).

Consumers may ask what may be the possible reason for AMC NoAH to offer pro-customer initiatives. It could be the growing tendency for mediclaim policyholders and the rich class to utilize corporate (high-end) hospitals for simple fever, surgery of hernia/hydrocele/appendicitis that can be easily managed in a nursing home having two to 75 beds facility. AMC NoAH wishes to correct this anomaly. As per one AMC NoAH official, “There is excellent quality of doctors at small nursing homes.”

On 28 January 2013, The Times of India carried an article on Mumbai’s nursing homes shutting shop. It quotes a doctor who shut his nursing home stating “Nursing homes are no longer sought after due to the popularity of insurance. People want to go to hospitals that are generally better equipped.” With value-added services, transparency and uniformity in procedures, AMC NoAH may be taking the steps to reverse this trend which could be bleeding its business.



nagesh kini

4 years ago

As one present at last PIL hearings in at the Bombay High Court heard by two judge bench presided by Chief Justice, I was dismayed by the absolutely callous and lack luster attitudes of the stake holders - particularly the medical fraternity comprising the family physicians, nursing homes and large multi-speciality hospitals offering Five and Seven Starred Hospital facilities charging equally exorbitant rates.
It is well known that doctors as well as hospitals and nursing homes always practice dual rates - one for patients reimbursed by insurance/employers and another paying out of their own. Their argument is "After all some one else is paying and not you. So it shouldn't make you any difference(!)" In the long for you and the premium shoots up to recoup this.
Despite being given enough opportunity by the Court to furnish a "bucket" or a range of rates high and low end for ailments,the consultants chose to select only 42 sickness without assigning any reasons as to why only these and not the others! The Association of Hospitals constituting essentially all of Mumbai's extremely high brow high end medical tourism hang outs chose to give a short shift to the High Court notice by filing a vague one page response conveying absolutely nothing meaningful at all.
The Insurance Regulator appeared to be taken aback on learning that insurance companies are incentivizing the TPAs to reduce and reject claims. TPAs are found to not only process but settle the claims acts that are in fact totally contrary to the Insurance Act and IRDA instructions. It was also conceded in the Court that complex high value claims are verified by under qualified unani, homeopaths, aryuvedics and veterinarians who merrily reject and reduce claims which the insurance companies are only to accept as it suits their bottom lines!

Supreme Infrastructure impresses; net profit jumps 43%

Supreme Infrastructure (one of our Street Beat picks) has posted good third quarter results, with strong sales and operating profit and got a good pipeline of orders during the third quarter. We had written about the stock when it was Rs290.80. It is now quoting at Rs205. As we had feared, is it cheap for a reason?

We had written about Supreme Infrastructure India (Supreme Infra), one of the leading infrastructure EPC companies in India, on 9 August 2012 ( Our article had clearly stated that “while its financial results make Supreme Infrastructure share an attractive buy at the current market price, investors should be cautious because there might be something in these numbers that we may not know and may turn out too good to be true.”

The company has reported impressive numbers despite the economy being sluggish for the greater part of 2012, especially during the third quarter ended December 2012. Supreme Infra reported 34% year-on-year (y-o-y) increase in net sales for the three quarter ended December 2012, at Rs550.28 crore when compared to Rs410.59 crore for the same period last year. Net profit numbers is more impressive as it recorded a 43% y-o-y jump to Rs35.92 crore for the third quarter of the 2012-13 fiscal. And yet, the stock is sharply down.

The company has not only exceeded its own expectations but its track record is also quite impressive. It has been reporting extremely consistent sales figures, which have been growing at double digits every successive quarter without a negative one since September 2009. Its average three quarter y-o-y average is 33% while net sales for the December 2012 quarter grew at 34%. Even more impressive is its operating efficiency. Its operating profit track record is even more impressive, growing at double digits and not one negative growth quarter. Its three-quarter y-o-y average growth rate is 31% while operating profit clock 37% growth rate. Despite a high return on net worth (29%), its valuation remains ridiculously low, with market capitalisation barely over 1x operating profit (annualised).

The company managed to add Rs505.25 crore worth of orders during the December 2012 quarter. Some of them are:

  • Order from Central Public Works Department worth Rs267 crore for construction of additional office complex for Supreme Court of India;
  • A contract from the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation worth Rs41.7 crore for construction of a rail depot-cum-workshop. The company has a 49% stake in the project;
  • A contract for building a multi-storied residential building, worth Rs94.87 crore, in Sector 66-A in Mohali;
  • A drainage contract from SPMU, ICZM Project, worth Rs41.40 crore, to develop drainage system at Digha, West Bengal.

    This pipeline of orders gives good revenue visibility for the next few quarters, assuming everything is executed as per contract with no delay. This is, however, anyone’s guess.


The stock price closed at Rs205 on the National Stock Exchange (NSE), down 2.29% for the day. As we had feared, the stock has disappointed despite excellent results and should be sold on the next rally.

Check here for all the company analysis that we do.

If you are interested in our stockletter segment, apart from Street Beat, then click here to subscribe.



Suiketu Shah

4 years ago

In Indian equity markets,the essential problem is almost every company worth its salt has a parallel blacvk money transaction route which makes it difficult for the normal investor to come to conclusions based on mere balance sheet and financial information submitted.Also its widely proven "wealth manaegement exporters" ,most of them are legalised cheats,crooks and frauds.

This is where ml is so useful as we get the best and most importantly "honest" research recommendations from experts with no bias.


Suiketu Shah

In Reply to Suiketu Shah 4 years ago

I am talking of undisclosed black money what most corporates do in a derogatory way pl note not an accepted way.

Vinayak Bhimarao Mudholkar

4 years ago

It's operating cash flow is bad.

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.

To continue

Sign Up or Sign In


To continue

Sign Up or Sign In



The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)