Regulations
Action on High Frequency Trading: SEBI says fact-finding exercise already underway
In a reply to a set of 51 questions raised by Moneylife on 12th September on high frequency trading in NSE, SEBI has just informed us that the issue is drawing its serious attention and that a fact-finding exercise is already underway
 
Market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) told Moneylife that its Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) has extensively discussed the issue of high frequency trading (HFT) and the matter is drawing its serious attention. SEBI was replying to a detailed email sent on 12 September 2015 by Sucheta Dalal, Managing Editor of Moneylife. It said, "We would like to thank you for taking efforts to flag the issue. We would like to inform you that a fact-finding exercise is already under way by SEBI. The matter has also been discussed extensively in the Technical Advisory Committee of SEBI and is drawing its serious attention. While we have noted the issues raised in your email, you will appreciate that we would not like to make comments on matters which are under investigation."
 
The same 51-point questionnaire was also sent to top executives of National Stock Exchange (NSE). However, there has been no response from the stock Exchange. In June this year, Moneylife had written about the allegations by a Whistleblower about NSE’s HFT operations in 2011-14 period . Moneylife had duly contacted NSE for its response before writing the article. On that occasion too, the NSE had refused to respond despite three attempts by Moneylife to elicit its views. After Moneylife published the articles on HFT , NSE filed a Rs100 crore defamation suit against Moneylife with prayers to remove the articles and stop Moneylife from writing further on the issue. A single Judge in Bombay High Court dismissed this. The judge also asked NSE to pay to Ms Dalal, Debashis Basu, Editor & Publisher of Moneylife Rs1.5 lakh each as cost and Rs47 lakh to two trusts, Tata Memorial Hospital and the Masina Hospital for free treatment of the poor. The Exchange has filed an appeal against that order. 
 
Of the 51 questions Moneylife had asked to SEBI and NSE, some the questions were:
  1. What is the additional information that a co-location user get vis-a-vis other brokers?
  2. What is the response time that NSE co-location users receive vis-a-vis non-co-location users? 
  3. How many physical co-location facilities does NSE have? Why is there more than one colocation? 
  4. What are the advantages a person will enjoy if he or she continued to get faster information vis-a-vis others in NSE co-location?
  5. What advantages do members in co-location receive vis-a-vis members who are not in co-location?
  6. What is the value of orders placed by members in last 5 years from NSE co-location? 
  7. Under which SEBI circular or guidelines did NSE start providing co-location facilities? If these services were started before any guidelines were formulated, did NSE ask for specific SEBI approval for starting such facilities?
  8. Were some NSE members ever allowed to log in ahead of others systematically?
Here is the reply we received from SEBI...
 
Subject: Your email to Chairman, SEBI with regard to complaint of a market participant against NSE
 
This has reference to your email dated September 12, 2015 to Chairman, SEBI wherein you had sought certain details regarding an anonymous complaint of a market participant against NSE.
 
We would like to thank you for taking efforts to flag the issue. We would like to inform you that a fact finding exercise is already under way by SEBI. The matter has also been discussed extensively in the Technical Advisory Committee of SEBI and is drawing its serious attention. While we have noted the issues raised in your email, you will appreciate that we would not like to make comments on matters which are under investigation. However, we would like to inform on the various measures taken by SEBI, in the recent past. 
 
SEBI has ensured that regulation of the securities market keeps pace with the dynamism displayed by the capital markets. SEBI has taken various proactive measures over the last few years to ensure that appropriate risk management framework is in place to address the risks associated with adoption of such technological advancements. 
 
In line with the above emphasis, SEBI was one of the first securities market regulators globally to put in place a framework for regulation of algorithmic trading. SEBI has also put-in place a regulatory framework to ensure fair and equitable access to the co-location facility and integrity and security of the data and trading systems. The regulatory framework was finalized after taking on-board views of the market participants through a discussion paper floated on May 03, 2013. High Frequency Trading (HFT) recently has drawn the attention of IOSCO too and the member jurisdictions are deliberating the impact of such trading on the market structure and market participants. SEBI is in the process of studying various issues involved and gather international experience to take further regulatory steps to regulate HFT.
 
In addition, SEBI has also issued circulars on various other technology related areas such as Cyber security and cyber resilience framework for stock exchanges, clearing corporation and depositories, Testing requirements for trading software, Business continuity planning and disaster recovery, Direct Market Access, Internet Based Trading, Safeguards to avoid trading disruption in case of failure of software vendor, etc.
 
We may like to state that SEBI would take all necessary steps in the interests of investors in securities and market integrity.

User

COMMENTS

n k gupta

1 year ago

Dear Ms Dalal,

My best wishes with moneylife team for wining HFT case and keepit up.

n k gupta

1 year ago

Dear Ms Dalal,
My best wishes to you regarding the matter of HFT.

Ramesh Gangappa

2 years ago

Good efforts. Congrats Money Life Team.

Raj K Swamy

2 years ago

By saying they are investigating, is the exchange admitting that the colocation facilities have been provided without studyiong the implications?

Balasubramanian

2 years ago

Congrats Money Life Team. Your work is really admirable.

manoharlalsharma

2 years ago

Action on High Frequency Trading: SEBI says fact-finding exercise already underway / it is common to all till do not intervening of COURT or POLITICIAN

vswami

2 years ago


“We may like to state that SEBI WOULD TAKE ALL NECESSARY STEPS IN the interests of investors in securities and market integrity.(bold FONT supplied)”

IMPROMPTU (OFFHAND - to share own unbiased perceptions):

Most of the points, rather tall claims, sought to be made and canvassed , in defence of the specific allegation (s) made , in the form of investigative inquiry by Moneylife, against the thus far continuing failure on the part of the regulatory authority, admittedly so, “to take all necessary steps “, go to serve as a clear pointer to the field reality; that is, that the authority has not considered it why it is of the utmost importance to keep a track, mentor and plug in the requisite corrective steps, on its own and in the normal course itself; and on a timely basis. This perforce brings to one’s mind the proverbial tomboyish act of thinking of and locking the doors of the stable, after the horse (s) has (ve) managed to and clean bolted away.
< Lock the barn door after the horse has bolted - Idioms by ...

Also the other commonly heard of story of the Lion King – its ruling the affairs in the jungle.

To quickly narrate (at the cost of repetition):

The Lion King told a miserable mouse,- as the RULER, me lay down the law for the jungle; but it is up to you to find self a satisfying and effective solution to any of own problems.

Point to ponder: Are our men in governance, or the bureaucracy, the so called and duly empowered regulators being no exception, so far as common memory goes, historically, any differently molded from / in comparison to the Lion King?

Over to the pro- activists at large in general, and to those @Moneylife with expert knowledge in particular, hoping for further incisive deliberation!

In the present context, it may not but be apt and worthwhile to pull out from the cupboard and have a relook through the special committee report on the topic of, - ‘functioning’ regulatory and semi regulatory authorities, in place for long.

Dr.Abhik De

2 years ago

But no action on churning/over transaction of mutual fund products byintermeiary/distributors.Wondered!

CVC seeks SC clarification on sharing confidential information
The Supreme Court will hear on November 12 the Central Vigilance Commission's (CVC) application seeking clarification whether it could share, with CBI's former special director M.L.Sharma, the confidential reports on coal block scam that it had submitted to the top court in sealed cover.
 
The coal bench of Justice Madan B. Lokur. Justice Kurian Joseph and Justice A.K.Sikri had appointed the Central Bureau of Investigation official M.L.Sharma to inquire whether the meetings that the then agency chief Ranjit Sinha had with the accused in coal block allocation scam in any way impacted the investigations or their final outcome.
 
The CVC has sought the clarification pointing to the "confidentiality" of the information sought by Sharma and the "nature and scope of the inquiry" to be undertaken by him as ordered by the apex court by its May 14, 2015 order.
 
The apex court by its September 14 order had allowed Sharma to access whatever records he felt necessary for the purposes of undertaking his inquiry.
 
Sharma, in a September 28 communication, asked the CVC to make available to him its comments on the investigation by the CBI in each of the 254 coal blocks. He has also asked the CVC to provide him the correspondence that might have been exchanged between it and the CBI on the subject. 
 
The report sought by Sharma from the CVC relates to one that the vigilance watchdog had submitted to the apex court in sealed cover after scrutinising the CBI investigation into each of 254 coal blocks whose allocation was under cloud. It had undertaken the screening of the CBI probe into the coal block allocation cases following the apex court's March 28, 2014 directions.
 
Disclaimer: Information, facts or opinions expressed in this news article are presented as sourced from IANS and do not reflect views of Moneylife and hence Moneylife is not responsible or liable for the same. As a source and news provider, IANS is responsible for accuracy, completeness, suitability and validity of any information in this article.

User

Mafia don Chhota Rajan held in Indonesia
Mafia don Rajendra Sadashiv Nikhalje alias Chhota Rajan -- former aide and strongman-turned-foe of fugitive Dawood Ibrahim -- has been arrested by the Indonesian police in Bali, top CBI officials said on Monday.
 
CBI director Anil Kumar Sinha confirmed the nabbing of Chhota Rajan, who operated from Mumbai and is wanted in India for a series of serious crimes and murders.
 
Union Home Minister Rajnath Singh thanked Interpol and the Indonesian government for their cooperation. "India was active on this case... I want to thank Interpol and Indonesian government for this. Post-verification, investigation will be taken forward," he told media persons in New Delhi.
 
Rajan, 55, operated from Chembur, a Mumbai suburb, and surroundings since the mid-1970s and later became a trusted henchman of Dawood Ibrahim Kaskar, the absconding don from Mumbai who is reportedly hiding in Pakistan.
 
Both fell out after the March 1993 Mumbai serial blasts and Chhota Rajan slipped out of India in 1995, remaining on the run till his arrest on Sunday.
 
According to available information, the mafia don -- declared a wanted man by Interpol since 1995 -- arrived by flight from Sydney, Australia, to Bali on Sunday afternoon and was arrested.
 
A CBI official said they have been pursuing the matter with Australian authorities. The probe agency also thanked Indonesia and Australia for their prompt action at their request.
 
"This is a good and close cooperation between India, Australia and Indonesia," the official added.
 
Despite repeated attempts, top police, bureaucratic and political officials in Maharashtra maintained a guarded silence and declined to comment on the developments which have immediate and long-term implications for Mumbai's underworld as well as Maharashtra's law and order.
 
Earlier, for a couple of hours on Monday, confusion reigned in top intelligence and police circles in Maharashtra with some officials claiming that another serial killer from Karnataka, Mohan Kumar alias Cyanide Mohan, had been arrested.
 
Disclaimer: Information, facts or opinions expressed in this news article are presented as sourced from IANS and do not reflect views of Moneylife and hence Moneylife is not responsible or liable for the same. As a source and news provider, IANS is responsible for accuracy, completeness, suitability and validity of any information in this article.

User

COMMENTS

manoharlalsharma

2 years ago

Mafia don Chhota Rajan held in Indonesia / what is your last arrested one , experience? what resulted ZERO.

We are listening!

Solve the equation and enter in the Captcha field.
  Loading...
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email
Close

To continue


Please
Sign Up or Sign In
with

Email

BUY NOW

The Scam
24 Year Of The Scam: The Perennial Bestseller, reads like a Thriller!
Moneylife Magazine
Fiercely independent and pro-consumer information on personal finance
Stockletters in 3 Flavours
Outstanding research that beats mutual funds year after year
MAS: Complete Online Financial Advisory
(Includes Moneylife Magazine and Lion Stockletter)